COST-EFFECTIVENESS OF MOLECULAR IGE IN VITRO DIAGNOSTICS (IVD) IN CHILDREN SUSPECTED WITH PEANUT ALLERGY COMPARED TO DOUBLE BLIND PLACEBO CONTROLLED FOOD CHALLENGE (DBPCFC) IN EU, USA AND JAPAN
Author(s)
Hermansson LL1, Glaumann S2, Borres M1, Elenius M3, Mascialino B4, Hubben GA5, Nilsson C61Thermo Fisher Scientific, Uppsala, Sweden, 2Södersjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden, 3Statisticon AB, Uppsala, Sweden, 44Pharma AB, Stockholm, Sweden, 5BaseCase, Berlin, Germany, 6Sachs' Children's Hospital, Södersjukhuset, Stockholm, Sweden
OBJECTIVES: In vitro diagnostic (IVD) has a considerable health economic impact: 60% of patients’ information derives from IVD tests, but IVD makes 1% of the total health care budget in EU (EDMA, 2010). No cost-effectiveness (CE) analyses are available on molecular IVD in allergy; only NICE in the UK made a CE study IgE IVD for peanut allergy (PA). Given the impact of PA on quality of life (Qaly), accurate diagnosis is crucial. 10% of children are considered peanut sensitised, but only 1-2% is true positive for PA. Subjects with IgE antibodies to allergens Ara h1-2-3 have high risk of allergic reactions (Astier, 2006). DBPCFC is the gold standard for food-allergy diagnosis; however it is time-consuming, expensive and might induce severe reactions (Nicolau, 2010). IVD can give clinicians a tool to decide the need of DBPCFC (Sastre, 2010); is IVD CE compared to DBPCFC in suspected PA children in EU, US and Japan? METHODS: Data was collected at Stockholm’s Sach´s Children's hospital (Nilsson, 2011) and from published literature. A 5-year Markov simulation model comparing IVD (ImmunoCap® - allergens f13, Ara h 1- 2-3-8-9) with DBPCFC was developed with Tree AgePro®, to analyse CE for IVD and the incremental cost per Qaly in suspected PA children. The sensitivity and specificity of each diagnostics determines the percentage of patients true-allergic, false-allergic, true-healthy and false-healthy. BaseCase® was used to interactively visualize results. Results are presented from the health care perspective; care giver indirect costs are included in a sensitivity analysis. RESULTS: IgE IVD is CE and cost saving for children with suspected PA in multiple countries compared to golden standard DBPCFC. CONCLUSIONS: IVD is a CE alternative to DBPCFC in selected patients in multiple countries. DBPCFC might be replaced in selected cases, still being useful in subjects with conflicting immunological/clinical results (Codreanu, 2011).
Conference/Value in Health Info
2012-06, ISPOR 2012, Washington, D.C., USA
Value in Health, Vol. 15, No. 4 (June 2012)
Code
PMD33
Topic
Economic Evaluation
Topic Subcategory
Cost-comparison, Effectiveness, Utility, Benefit Analysis
Disease
Respiratory-Related Disorders