A COMPARISON OF CLINICAL TRIAL PARTICIPANTS TO THE GENERAL PATIENT POPULATION IN FRANCE, GERMANY AND UNITED KINGDOM
Author(s)
Susan C. Bolge, PhD, Senior Director of Outcomes Research, Hema Kannan, MPH, Manager of Outcomes Research Consumer Health Sciences, Princeton, NJ, USA
OBJECTIVES: To identify and describe differences in demographics, quality of life, resource utilization, and healthcare attitudes between clinical trials participants and the general population. METHODS: Data for this analysis were obtained from the 2005 National Health and Wellness Survey (NHWS), an annual nationally representative Internet-based study of the health status, healthcare attitudes, and behaviors of adults (age 18+). The current analysis was limited to respondents from France, Germany and the UK reporting a diagnosis of hypertension, high cholesterol, or diabetes (n=8,384). Respondents reported ever participating in a clinical drug trial, demographic, attitudes, resource use, and quality of life (SF-8 summary scores). RESULTS: Across all countries, 6% (n=472) reported ever participating in a clinical drug trial (France, 4%; Germany, 6%; UK, 7%). In all countries, clinical trial participants were older ( France, 59.19 vs. 52.26, p<0.01; Germany, 56.30 vs. 52.64, p<0.01; UK, 59.93 vs. 56.01, p<0.01), and had more frequent physician visits (France, 9.17 vs. 1.01, p=0.01; Germany, 10.27 vs. 7.47, p<0.001; UK, 6.51 vs. 5.60, p=0.03). Clinical trials participants in France and Germany reported lower physical quality of life (France, 42.98 vs. 45.91, p<0.01; Germany, 41.97 vs. 44.11, p=0.01) than the general population. Only trial participants in Germany had lower mental quality of life (47.38 vs. 49.74, p<0.01) and significantly more emergency room visits and hospitalizations. Trial participants in France were less likely to have insurance than the general population (86.41% vs. 94.44%, p<0.01). Clinical trial participants in the UK were more likely than the general UK population to report a preference for prescription vs. OTC medications (50.50 vs. 42.02, p=0.02). CONCLUSION: Clinical trial participants are intrinsically different from the general population. This should be considered in the design and implementation of clinical trials and the generalization of results to the population.
Conference/Value in Health Info
2007-05, ISPOR 2007, Arlington, VA, USA
Value in Health, Vol. 10, No.3 (May/June 2007)
Code
PMC16
Topic
Clinical Outcomes
Topic Subcategory
Clinical Outcomes Assessment
Disease
Multiple Diseases