A USER-FRIENDLY TOOL FOR EVALUATING AND IMPROVING THE TRANSFERABILITY OF ECONOMIC EVALUATION RESULTS BETWEEN COUNTRIES
Author(s)
Welte R1, Feenstra TL2, Jager JC2, Leidl R1, 1University of Ulm, Ulm, Germany; 2National Institute of Public Health and the Environment, Bilthoven, Netherlands
OBJECTIVE: Development of a user-friendly tool for the evaluation and improvement of the transferability of economic evaluation results. METHODS: We systematically identified the factors that may influence the transfer of study results and investigated the way they impact transferability. A transferability decision chart was developed that includes knock out criteria, a checklist based on the transferability factors, and methods for improving transferability and for assessing the uncertainty of transferred results. The decision chart was applied to various international cost-effectiveness studies. RESULTS: Economic evaluation results can be transferred pending the outcomes of the transferability check and necessary adjustments. The influence of differences of most transferability factors can be estimated via the key health economic determinants capacity utilization, effectiveness, productivity loss and returns to scale. Depending on the results of the transferability check an adjustment of the study results for inflation and for differences related to currencies or purchasing power might be sufficient. Otherwise, modeling based corrections might be necessary for which the (re)-building of the study model is required. Univariate sensitivity analysis seems appropriate for identification of the most important adjustments. If not all relevant study parameters can be substituted with country specific ones, multivariate or probabilistic sensitivity analysis appears to be a promising way to quantify the uncertainty associated with a transfer. If study results cannot be transferred, the transfer of study models or designs should be investigated as this can save a substantial amount of time when conducting a new study. CONCLUSIONS: The transferability decision chart is a transparent and user-friendly tool for evaluating and improving the transferability of economic evaluation results. For the assessment of transferability, a detailed method description in the original study is necessary. In addition, the relevant data should be presented in a non-aggregated manner for enabling modeling adjustment.
Conference/Value in Health Info
2003-11, ISPOR Europe 2003, Barcelona, Spain
Value in Health, Vol. 6, No. 6 (November/December 2003)
Code
ME2
Topic
Economic Evaluation
Topic Subcategory
Cost/Cost of Illness/Resource Use Studies
Disease
Multiple Diseases