EFFECTIVENESS OF MINIMALLY INVASIVE SURGERY FOR TOTAL HIP ARTHROPLASTY
Author(s)
Navarro Espigares JL1, Hernandez Torres E1, Ruiz Arranz JL2, Padial Ortiz MA1, Aranda Villalobos P31HOSPITAL UNIVERSITARIO VIRGEN DE LAS NIEVES, GRANADA, Spain, 2AREA SANITARIA SERRANIA DE RONDA, RONDA, Spain, 3Hospital Universitario Virgen de las Nieves,
OBJECTIVES: The main objective of this review is to determine the effectiveness of total hip arthroplasty with MIS compare to the traditional approach. Specifically, this appraisal aims to answer questions related to functionality, quality of life, and clinical results. METHODS: The bibliographic review was conducted in two phases: an initial phase of search for appropriate studies and a second phase of selection according to previously established criteria. The search for articles was carried out in major databases and subsequently in bibliographical references for the studies found. The databases reviewed were MEDLINE/PubMed/MeSH Database, EMBASE, Economic Evaluation Database/DARE/HTA, CSIC/EMI-Biomedicine, and ScienceDirect Collection. The search period was limited to the years 2003 to 2009. The selection of items was made at an early stage by screening article summaries followed by full texts. RESULTS: We initially selected more than 600 studies, 78 for detailed evaluation, and 32 final studies for inclusion in the review. The results of this review are presented in two sections. The first represents the main descriptive characteristics of the studies selected in favor of MIS (19), and the second presents the unfavorable studies (13). Among the main benefits we found a decrease of transfusion requirements, better mobilization and rehabilitation, low dislocation, reduced surgical time, shorter hospital stays, less soft tissue damage, and better short term results. The main drawbacks were increased risks of complications, malposition of prosthesis, healing problems, and irrelevant clinical incision size and functionality. CONCLUSIONS: The studies presented in this review show clear evidence of how MIS influences the effectiveness related to functional outcomes, hospital stays, and surgical aggressiveness of the intervention. In this regard, we found a greater number of comparable studies supporting minimally invasive surgery in terms of effectiveness than those that emphasize complications and disadvantages of this technique.
Conference/Value in Health Info
2011-11, ISPOR Europe 2011, Madrid, Spain
Value in Health, Vol. 14, No. 7 (November 2011)
Code
PSU25
Topic
Health Service Delivery & Process of Care
Topic Subcategory
Hospital and Clinical Practices
Disease
Multiple Diseases