IS THERE A LEARNING CURVE ASSOCIATED WITH EXERCISE TRAINING IN PATIENTS WITH HEART FAILURE?
Author(s)
Yanhong Li, MS, Clinical Research Manager1, Joelle Y Friedman, MPA, Project Leader1, Kate L Compton, BS, Graduate student2, Janice P Tzeng, BSPH, Graduate student3, Kevin A Schulman, MD, Professor1, Shelby D Reed, PhD, Associate Professor11Duke Clinical Research Institute, Durham, NC, USA; 2 University of North Carolina, Durham, NC, USA; 3 University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC, USA
Objective: Estimating the cost-effectiveness of disease management programs requires a comprehensive assessment of personnel and patient time. Assessments at a single time point may under- or overestimate the time required to perform related activities. In this study, we use data from a large clinical trial of exercise therapy in patients with heart failure to evaluate whether there is evidence of a learning curve with regard to time spent on non-exercise activities across 36 supervised exercise training sessions across 12 weeks. Methods: As part of the economic evaluation planned alongside the NIH-sponsored HF-ACTION trial, a Provider and Patient Time Assessment Survey was administered across 9 study sites representing a subset of 56 patients. The survey was designed to assess provider time with and without the patient, pre- and post-exercise, to account for a variety of related tasks (e.g. pulling charts, patient education, scheduling, etc.). Linear growth models were used to model the trajectory change of time spent on ‘non-exercise' activities across 36 visits. Results: Data were available for 39 (69.6%) patients who completed all 36 exercise sessions, 7 (12.5%) patients who were still enrolled in ongoing exercise training, and 10 (17.9%) patients who discontinued exercise training. The average non-exercise time associated with supervised training was 30.3 (SD=19.8) minutes, comprised of 20.6 minutes spent with patients and 9.5 minutes without patients. After adjusting for whether warm-up/cool-down activities were included, the total time spent on non-exercise activities decreased significantly (parameter estimate:-1.04 minutes/ week; p=0.007), with approximately equal reductions in time with patients (-0.57 minutes/week; p= 0.038), and without patients (-0.65 minutes/week; p= 0.058) over 12 weeks. Conclusion: Our analysis suggests that providers and patients experienced efficiency gains in regard to time spent on activities associated with supervised exercise training. These results demonstrate the potential importance of comprehensive time assessment when evaluating disease management programs.
Conference/Value in Health Info
2008-05, ISPOR 2008, Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Value in Health, Vol. 11, No. 3 (May/June 2008)
Code
PCV97
Topic
Health Service Delivery & Process of Care
Topic Subcategory
Hospital and Clinical Practices
Disease
Cardiovascular Disorders, Sensory System Disorders