INCORPORATING EQUITY IN COST-EFFECTIVENESS ANALYSIS- A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW
Author(s)
Johri M1, Norheim OF21Université de Montréal, Montreal, QC, Canada, 2University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway
OBJECTIVES: Limited use of economic evaluation in decision-making may in part reflect neglect of equity concerns. We reviewed published studies describing formal methods to integrate equity into cost-effectiveness and cost-utility analyses (CEA). METHODS: Candidate articles were identified via a search of Pub Med and EMBASE databases without language or date restrictions, and hand-searching of article bibliographies. All original research articles, reviews, commentaries or editorials describing formal methods to integrate equity into CEA were candidates for inclusion. To select studies, candidate titles, abstracts and full text articles were reviewed independently by each author. Review was not blinded. Authors jointly determined study inclusion on the basis of individual assessments and discussion. Disagreements of opinion were resolved by consensus. Articles were excluded if they met one or more of the following criteria: not about CEA, not about equity, not a formal proposal, not an original proposal, proposal lacking in specificity. To facilitate narrative synthesis, articles were classified into families of approaches based on consensus groupings established jointly by the authors. RESULTS: The search identified 679 potentially relevant studies, of which 93 were retrieved for detailed (full text) evaluation following a review of titles and abstracts. After full-text screening an additional 47 studies were excluded, yielding 46 studies for review. Studies were classified into the following approaches to equity: equity weighting by age (n=8), gender (n=1) or disease severity (n=7); social welfare function approaches (n=10) ; mathematical programming (n=8) ; dispersion and concentration of health benefits (n=3) ; proportionalism (n=4) ; and multicriteria proposals (n=5). Most (n=40) described theoretical proposals. CONCLUSIONS: There exists a wide variety of formal methods to incorporate equity into CEA; however, their potential has not been fully exploited. To enhance viability and uptake, specific recommendations are made for further methodological development and increased links with normative theory.
Conference/Value in Health Info
2009-10, ISPOR Europe 2009, Paris, France
Value in Health, Vol. 12, No. 7 (October 2009)
Code
EE6
Topic
Health Policy & Regulatory
Topic Subcategory
Health Disparities & Equity
Disease
Multiple Diseases